The ATO’s updated guidance on employee / contractor distinction TR 2023/4 Pay as You Go Withholding – who is an employee?
The ATO has now finalised its ruling TR 2023/4 that explains how to determine whether a worker should be classified as an employee for PAYG withholding purposes. The ruling focuses on determining whether someone is an employee under the ordinary meaning of the term but doesn’t look at the extended definition of employee that is used in the context of the superannuation guarantee system.
The ATO continues to emphasise that whether an individual is an employee is a question of fact to be determined based on an assessment of the entire relationship between the parties.
In line with more recent High Court decisions in this area, if the worker and engaging entity have committed the terms of the relationship into a written contract, then the analysis needs to be performed with reference to the legal rights and obligations in that written contract.
The key focus is on the terms of the contract, rather than the labels used by the parties to describe the relationship.Â
Where a contract is not comprehensively committed in writing, the ATO now makes it more clear in the final ruling that the subsequent conduct of the parties can be relevant to work out the contractual terms that have been agreed to by the parties.
In determining whether a worker should be classified as an employee, there are still a range of factors that need to be considered.
The ATO indicates that the key distinction between an employee and an independent contractor is that:
- An employee serves in the business of an employer, performing their work as part of that business;
- An independent contractor provides services to a principal’s business, but the contractor does so in furthering their own business enterprise; they carry out the work as principal of their own business, not as part of another.
In addition to whether the worker is serving as part of the engaging entity’s business, it is also important to consider the extent to which the business has a contractual right to control how, where and when the workers perform their work.Â
Aside from these two key factors there are a number of other indicators that could be relevant in classifying the worker, including:
- The ability to delegate work;
- Whether the contract is on a results basis;
- Which party provides the tools and equipment;
- Risk; and
- Generation of goodwill.
Consistent with the draft ruling, the ATO considers that where a worker engages to perform work for a business as a partner of a partnership or through a company or trust then this may indicate an intention by all parties not to create an employment relationship. However, a different conclusion may be reached if a worker uses an interposed entity but is also directly a party to the contract with the engaging entity.
If you need help understanding your employment or contractor PAYG tax and superannuation obligations, our accountants can help.












